Wood vs Plastic Toilet Seats -The Pros & Cons + Which is the Best?

Wood vs Plastic Toilet Seats

As part of our commitment to quality, we search for and compare all the top products you can find on Amazon.com. As an Amazon affiliate, we could be compensated if you click on the links and buy something. (At no additional charge).

Wood and plastic toilet seat are two of the best toilet seats right now. If you are looking for the best bang for the buck, you cannot really go wrong with either of these materials. But if you had to compare wood vs. plastic toilet seats which one comes out on top?

That’s what this article is all about. We’ll deep dive into both of these toilet seats and find out how they compare to each other in various aspects that are important to you as a user. Both of them offer everything you need from a toilet seat, however they have a few differences that can greatly affect your final choice. As an expert we understand the important differences between these two.
This wood vs. plastic toilet seat comparison article aims to help you understand those differences so you can make an informed decision, so let’s get started!

If you’re in a hurry, check the “winner” of this comparison guide down below.

Wood vs. Plastic Toilet Seat Comparison Table

Features Plastic Toilet SeatWood Toilet Seat
Durability Lasts longerDegrades each you clean with a detergent
Style and design Glossy, modern, timeless designUnique antique appeal
Scratch resistance Scratch-resistantPoor resistance to scratches
Pricing Lower price tagHigher price tag
Ease of cleaning Glossy and easy to cleanProblematic to clean

Winner

From our point of view, we’ve settled on a draw, but why? There are a lot of things to consider and it was very hard to choose a winner between them. It all depends on personal preference. Both wood and toilet seat are so good that you can just choose one on a whim and not lose much. But for those of you who want to know more about the differences between them, let’s get started.


Wood Vs Plastic Toilet Seats

Generally speaking plastic and wooden toilets have seemingly identical functionality and today it can be really hard to decide which one to pick over the other, barring minimal price differences. In terms of appearance, plastic toilets come in white or plain solid color while the wooden toilet is sleeker, warmer traditional looking. But a buyer would want to learn more about the differences between these two toilet seats.

What are these other differences?

Let’s find out.
Features
The first part of our wood vs. plastic toilet set comparison is about the uniqueness of features.
Both of the toilets offer all the basic features you’d expect from a toilet seat:
So instead of listing every feature that they have and comparing them, we’re going to focus on the unique features instead.

Wood Toilet Seat Unique Features
Wood toilet seat prides itself as a warmer, stylish, and more comfortable toilet seat.

Here are some of the unique features

1. Style and Design
The name does give it away. Wooden toilets are made out of either wood or composite material with a finish that makes it look like wood. Several times, these wooden seats will be made up of particleboard and then polished to mimic the look and the style of solid wooden toilet seats. Most people have this set idea of what a wooden toilet seat will look like and it usually involves a light-colored toilet seat or a dark colored one with an antique appeal that mimics the look of oak.

These wooden seats are cut out of wood planks and then coated and polished with a layer of varnish. To accentuate the authentic old-time look of a toilet seat, they use brass hinges with darker colored woods and nickel hinges with lighter colored woods-like pine.

2. Durability
Wooden toilet seats are prone to degrading due to moisture, insect bites, and frequent use of detergents. Wood seats can warp and crack in high humidity or heat and the protective coating can also wear down. They are also susceptible to scratches during cleaning. This is something that does not happen with plastic toilet seats.

3. Comfort
Heated toilet seats are an added feature in toilet seats to make one comfortable during a cold, dreary period. Wooden toilet seats also have this feature even though wood can trap some of its heat, unlike plastic toilet seats. Enameled wood toilet seats retain heat even better making one feel more comfortable. So if you don’t want to freeze on your toilet seat, you might go for a wood toilet seat.

4. Ease of Cleaning
Wooden toilet seats can dampen down if not treated from not absorbing moisture. Plastic toilet seats, on the other hand, do not absorb moisture and thus they are comfortable to clean. Plastic is known to have a glossy, easy to clean the surface with a water-repellant surface due to the vinyl lamination.

5. Price tag
In terms of pricing, a light plastic toilet seat with no cushion or reinforcement can be as cheap as a few dollars whereas a wood toilet set might cost hundreds of dollars. Some manufacturers of wood toilet seats though produce wood toilet seats from cheap wood compared to the rare and unknown ones to make them more affordable while maintaining the rich and classy designs.

The downside of these cheaper wooden lids though is that first, they may have used chemicals that are harmful to the skin. Additionally, the wooden lids may not last long.


Pros and Cons of Wooden Toilet Seats

ProsCons
Stylish designRelatively More Expensive
ComfortableHarder to clean
Traditional and timeless lookLess durable
Luxurious look and feelLess resistant to scratches
Warm and invitingHeavier

Plastic Toilet Seat Unique Features

Before the advent of plastic toilet seats, it was wood or nothing. When plastic seats came they were regarded as more hygienic than wood. Plastic is a basic description of a range of synthetic materials from polypropylene to acrylic resin. Acrylic resins are available in clear or translucent colors. This means you can embed objects in the resin such as seashells, dried flowers, and pictures.

Right now, plastic toilet seats boast the following unique features:

1. Easy To Clean
The glossy, water-repellant surface of plastic makes them stress-free when cleaning. They don’t easily scratch and you can clean as many times as possible with a detergent without compromising on the structure of the surface. Also as regards moisture and other stuff, it will simply sit on top and you can easily wipe it off. This gives the plastic toilet seat an edge in terms of hygiene and cleaning.

2. Price tag
With regards to pricing, plastic toilet seats are cheaper compared to the traditional wood counterpart. So choosing either wood or plastic toilet seat depends on your budget. If you’re looking for something functional, hygienic, and budget-friendly, you should consider a plastic toilet seat.

3. Comfort
Without heaters, plastic toilet seats are cold and uncomfortable especially during winter months because plastic toilet seats cannot trap their heat. So if you don’t want to freeze whenever you use the toilet seat, use a wooden toilet seat or invest in one with a heater element.

4. Long-lasting
Plastic toilet seats are resistant to warping and cracking. They are also resistant to scratches and fading even with frequent use of detergents. Though modern wooden toilet seats are scratch-resistant thanks to the protective coating, this coating might wear down over time. If the wood is exposed, it results in warping.

5. Appearance
Plastic toilet seats are in plain and solid white color which looks boring compared to its nice, warm, and inviting wooden counterpart. Wooden toilet seats complement most existing décor better than plastic toilet seats.


Pros and Cons of Plastic Toilet Seats

ProsCons
Less expensiveUncomfortable
Easier to cleanAesthetic unattractive
Scratch-resistantBasic design
DurableLess sturdy
Modern looking

Bottom Line

The toilet seat is an important household item and it’s appreciated more for its functionality rather than its appearance. So it all depends on your personal preference. Before you go out and buy the toilet seat, there are a few tips that’ll ensure you get the best like:
Type
Depending on several factors some as discussed above, you can decide on whether you prefer a plastic or wood toilet seat.
Cost
Almost everyone wants to save money as they are shopping and the same applies when you want to get a toilet seat. So depending on your budget, choose wisely.

Color and design
Toilet seats are found in different colors and designs where one is given the liberty to select the ones that will work out well for them. This ensures that one does not have to redecorate the house to facilitate the toilet seat as they can get one that blends in well with the décor to keep the great look of the house. One can also pick out a unique design that they can use to make the toilet look interesting.

Toilet hinges
The market is loaded with a wide variety of toilet seat hinges where you can pick the most appropriate one. Ensure you know the type of toilet seat you are using so that it can be fitted in well without any problem.

Elongated or Round Toilet Seat
Depending on the members of your household, you can decide which one will work best. If you have kids, you should fit their toilet with a round toilet whereas, for adults, elongated toilet seats are the most comfortable.

Slow close feature
This feature is included in both wood and plastic seats. To avoid unpleasant noises, toilets have an added slow closing feature which allows the lid to close slowly with just a tap.

American Standard Round Front Toilet Seat (White) Champion Slow-Close 5320B65CT.020

American Standard Champion Toilet Seat is one ideal choice toilet seat for anyone who is budget-minded. This plastic toilet seat will be a welcome addition to your home because it has all the basic applications one can look for.

It’s made from a high-quality polypropylene material that’s lightweight, non-absorbent, and stain-resistant. No need to worry about its elongated seat shape because it fits even on non-standard toilets and it’s available in elongated and round shapes.

The American Standard Champion Toilet Seat is engineered for convenience. Its closed front type of toilet depicts contemporary style and it’s resistant to slamming chipping, staining, and fading. It boasts of the Slow Close feature that prevents the seat and the lid from slamming.

You only get into contact with the lid when you gently tap it to close it. It also promotes hygiene for you thanks to quick release hinges where the seat can easily be removed for cleaning purposes. There are no tools required for its removal.

Offered at a meager price, it’s designed to complement any décor. Its sturdy solid color throughout is resistant to scratches fading and chipping and the 4 seats tight bumper maintains the stability of the seat keeping it in place preventing it from shifting. It can be set in just a matter of minutes all thanks to its quick attached hardware which speeds up the installation process.

Product Features

  • Dimensions: 16.81 x 14.31 x 2 inches (round)
  • Shape: elongated and round
  • Material: polypropylene
  • The slow-Close feature helps prevents slamming
  • Color: white
  • Mounting hardware and installation manual included

Pros

  • Resistant to staining, fading, chipping, and peeling
  • Fast and secure installation
  • Value for money
  • Sturdy
  • Easy to clean
  • No loud slamming
  • Durable

Cons

  • Flimsy mounting system

You may also be interested in:

Most Stain Resistant Toilet Seats

Best Most Comfortable Toilet Seats

Best Seniors Padded Toilet Seats


FAQS

Are Wooden Toilet Seats Sanitary?

The finishing on wooden toilet seats protects it from water and urine; keeping the toilet seat sanitary. Nonetheless, when the protective layer wears off, the wooden seat can get wet and soak the wood. Consequently, the exposed porous material of wood will start hosting germs and bacteria.
Therefore to keep the toilet seat sanitary, it needs to be well-maintained and avoiding slamming. Tiny cracks on the toilet seat will more likely provide a great breeding ground for bacteria and likely to harbor urine smell.

How to Maintain a Wooden Toilet Seat

Wood toilet seat is not scratch resistant and not as durable as plastic seats. So to maintain the wooden seat, consider using non-abrasive cloths or sponges when cleaning. Use an antibacterial soap, hydrogen peroxide, or rubbing alcohol to kill germs. Ensure to rinse the seat with clean water and wipe it down with a dry, soft cloth. Leave the toilet lid open to allow the hinges to air dry. Moisture on the wood surface can be a breeding ground for bacteria, fungus, and mold.

In case you have a cracked toilet seat consider inserting some wood glue with the nozzle of the dispenser. Once inserting the glue clamp the crack closed. After clamping, wipe any excess wood glue.

When cleaning the toilet seat use mild hand soap and water. Do not use acid, detergents, bleach, scouring powder, essential oils, chlorine, pine, oils, and disinfectants, or products in aerosol cans.

Do Plastic Toilet Seats Stain?

A white toilet seat can be exposed to the build-up of minerals from hard water. To prevent stains, you can use bleach, baking soda, or vinegar. Use ¼ cup of baking soda and mix it with ½ cup of warm water in a bowl. It should have a paste-type consistency; smear this mixture onto the stained areas and let sit for 15 to 20 minutes then proceed to wipe with a damp rag or sponge.

Why Are Toilet Seats Split In the Front?

Public toilets are split because they follow a plumbing code for a public toilet. They are industry-accepted standards adopted by many municipalities. These municipalities often write the UPC into their local codes.

So according to American Standard National Plumbing Code (ASNPC) all seats of water closets provided for public use should be of open-front type. The purpose of this design is to prevent genitals from being in contact with the lid while leaving an area of the seat that could be contaminated with urine and avoids contact for easier wiping.

Later on a global industry guideline called the Uniform Plumbing Code, outdated the American Standard National Plumbing Code, and has since enforced open-front toilet seats for public toilets. Thus the real answer lies in the reason why they are part of the public plumbing code. The U shape design of the seat is to make cleanup easier for women. This design gave ladies more access and allowed them to use the toilet without the risk of touching the porcelain.

How Do You Disinfect a Wooden Toilet Seat

You use bleach, baking soda, or vinegar. They all work fine. If you are using bleach, start by removing the toilet seat from the toilet and soak in bleach and water solution, after a few minutes, scrub until it’s clean. Rinse and fix it back to the toilet.

For vinegar, mix with water in a bowl and wipe down the seat using a soft piece of cloth or a sponge pros and cons of wooden toilet seats. Pour clean water then rinse the toilet seat thoroughly.

Wood vs plastic toilet seats
Wood vs plastic toilet seats reddit