Wood vs Plastic Toilet Seat -The Pros & Cons + Which is the Best?

Wood vs Plastic Toilet Seat

Disclaimer: BestOsmosisExperts is supported by readers. If you purchase something via links on this post, we may earn an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.

Right now, the nicest toilet seats are made of wood or plastic. If you want to get the most bang for your buck, you can’t go wrong with either of these materials. But, if you had to choose between wood and plastic toilet seats, which would you choose?

That is the topic of this article. We’ll do a deep dive into each of these toilet seats to see how they differ in many elements that are essential to you as a user.

Both provide everything you need in a toilet seat, but there are a few variances that can have a significant impact on your final decision. As experts, we understand the critical distinctions between these two.

This post compares wood vs. plastic toilet seats in order to help you understand the differences and make a more informed decision, so let’s get started!

Plastic vs Wooden Toilet Seat Comparison Table

Features Plastic Toilet SeatWood Toilet Seat
Durability Lasts longerDegrades each you clean with a detergent
Style and design Glossy, modern, timeless designUnique antique appeal
Scratch resistance Scratch-resistantPoor resistance to scratches
Pricing Lower price tagHigher price tag
Ease of cleaning Glossy and easy to cleanProblematic to clean

Winner

From our perspective, we’ve decided on a tie, but why? There are numerous factors to consider, and it was difficult to select a winner from the comparison table above.

It all comes down to personal preference. Both wood and toilet seats are so nice that you can choose one on a whim and not be disappointed.

Top Plastic Toilet Seat

White American Standard 5320B65CT.020 Slow – Close Toilet Seat


Top Wooden Toilet Seat

Molded Wood Round Toilet Seat with Zinc Alloy Hinges Anti-pinch Wooden Toilet Seat by Angol Shiold


But, for those of you who are interested in learning more about the differences between them.

Wood Vs Plastic Toilet Seats

In general, plastic and hardwood toilets appear to have comparable functioning, and it can be difficult to choose one over the other today, excluding minor pricing differences.

Plastic toilets are available in white or a single solid color, whereas wooden toilets are sleeker, warmer, and more traditional in appearance.

A buyer, on the other hand, would like to learn more about the distinctions between these two toilet seats.

What are these other differences?

The first element of our comparison of wood vs. plastic toilet sets is about the uniqueness of features.

Both toilets have all of the standard characteristics you’d expect from a toilet seat: Instead of listing and comparing all of their characteristics, we’ll concentrate on the ones that set them apart.

Wood Toilet Seat Unique Features
Wood toilet seat prides itself as a warmer, stylish, and more comfortable toilet seat.

1. Style and Design

The name is self-explanatory. Wooden toilets are made of wood or a composite material that has been finished to seem like wood.

These wooden seats will be composed of particleboard and polished several times to mimic the look and style of solid wooden toilet seats.

Most people have a preconceived notion of what a wooden toilet seat should look like, which usually involves a light-colored toilet seat or a dark-colored one with an antique appeal that resembles the appearance of oak.

These wooden seats are made from wood planks that have been varnished and polished. They utilize brass hinges with darker colored woods and nickel hinges with lighter colored woods, such as pine, to enhance the original old-time aspect of a toilet seat.

2. Durability
Moisture, insect bites, and frequent detergent usage all contribute to the deterioration of wooden toilet seats.
In extreme humidity or heat, wood seats can distort and break, and the protective coating might wear away.

They are also prone to scratches when being cleaned. This is not something that happens with plastic toilet seats.

3. Comfort
Heated toilet seats are a feature that is added to toilet seats to make them more pleasant during a cold, dismal season. Wooden toilet seats have this feature as well, despite the fact that wood, unlike plastic toilet seats, may trap some of its heat.

Enameled wood toilet seats retain heat even better, helping you feel more at ease. If you don’t want to freeze on your toilet seat, a wood toilet seat is a good option.

4. Ease of Cleaning
Wooden toilet seats can become damp if not coated to prevent moisture absorption. Plastic toilet seats, on the other hand, do not collect moisture, making them easy to clean. Because of the vinyl lamination, plastic has a glossy, easy-to-clean surface with a water-repellent surface.

5. Price tag

A light plastic toilet seat with no cushion or reinforcement can be purchased for a few dollars, but a wood toilet set can cost hundreds of dollars. Some manufacturers of wood toilet seats, on the other hand, build wood toilet seats from inexpensive wood rather than rare and unknown woods in order to keep the rich and classy designs accessible.

The disadvantage of these less expensive wooden lids is that they may have been made with chemicals that are hazardous to the skin. Furthermore, the wooden covers may not survive long.


Pros and Cons of Wooden Toilet Seats

ProsCons
Stylish designRelatively More Expensive
ComfortableHarder to clean
Traditional and timeless lookLess durable
Luxurious look and feelLess resistant to scratches
Warm and invitingHeavier

Plastic Toilet Seat Unique Features

Prior to the invention of plastic toilet seats, it was either wood or nothing. When plastic seats were introduced, they were thought to be more sanitary than wood seats.

Plastic is a broad term for a variety of synthetic materials ranging from polypropylene to acrylic resin. Acrylic resins can have either transparent or translucent colors.

This implies that you can incorporate materials such as seashells, dried flowers, and photographs in the resin.

Right now, plastic toilet seats boast the following unique features:

1. Easy To Clean
Plastic’s gleaming, water-repellent surface makes cleaning a breeze. They are not readily scratched, and you may clean them as many times as you like with a detergent without damaging the surface’s structure.

In terms of moisture and other debris, it will simply rest on top and can be easily wiped away. In terms of hygiene and cleaning, this gives the plastic toilet seat an advantage.

2. Price tag
In terms of cost, plastic toilet seats are less expensive than their wooden counterparts. So whether you choose a wooden or plastic toilet seat is determined on your budget.

A plastic toilet seat is a good option if you want something that is functional, hygienic, and inexpensive.

3. Comfort
Plastic toilet seats are cold and uncomfortable without heaters, especially during the winter months, because plastic toilet seats cannot trap heat.

If you don’t want to freeze every time you use the toilet, use a wooden toilet seat or purchase one with a warming element.

4. Long-lasting
Plastic toilet seats are not susceptible to warping or cracking. They are also resistant to scratches and fading, even when exposed to harsh detergents on a regular basis.

Despite the fact that modern hardwood toilet seats are scratch-resistant due to a protective coating, this coating may wear away with time. Warping occurs when the wood is exposed.

5. Appearance
Plastic toilet seats are straightforward and solid white, making them appear dull in comparison to their beautiful, warm, and inviting wooden equivalent. Wooden toilet seats look better with most existing décor than plastic toilet seats.


Pros and Cons of Plastic Toilet Seats

ProsCons
Less expensiveUncomfortable
Easier to cleanAesthetic unattractive
Scratch-resistantBasic design
DurableLess sturdy
Modern looking

Bottom Line

The toilet seat is an essential household item that is valued for its functionality rather than its looks. So it all comes down to personal preference. Before you go out and buy a toilet seat, here are a few pointers to keep in mind:
Type
You can choose between a plastic or wood toilet seat based on a variety of criteria, some of which have already been mentioned.
Cost
Almost everyone wants to save money when shopping, and the same is true when purchasing a toilet seat. Choose wisely based on your budget.

Color and design
Toilet seats are available in a variety of colors and styles, allowing users to choose the ones that are best suited to their needs.

This means that one does not have to redecorate the house to accommodate the toilet seat because they can find one that mixes in nicely with the décor and maintains the house’s beautiful look. One can also choose a one-of-a-kind design to make the toilet look intriguing.

Toilet hinges
The market is brimming with a plethora of toilet seat hinges from which to select the most suited one. Ascertain that you are aware of the type of toilet seat you are employing so that it can be properly installed.

Elongated or Round Toilet Seat
You can choose which one is best for your family based on their needs. If you have children, you should install a circle toilet, but elongated toilet seats are the most comfortable for adults.

Slow close feature
Both wood and plastic seats have this property. Toilets include a slow closing feature that allows the lid to close gently with simply a tap to eliminate unwanted noises.

American Standard Round Front Toilet Seat (White) Champion Slow-Close 5320B65CT.020

The American Standard Champion Toilet Seat is an excellent alternative for those on a tight budget. This plastic toilet seat will be a pleasant addition to your home because it has all of the essential applications.

It’s composed of high-quality polypropylene, which is lightweight, non-absorbent, and stain-resistant. There’s no need to be concerned about its extended seat design because it fits even on non-standard toilets and comes in elongated and circular shapes.

The American Standard Champion Toilet Seat is designed for comfort. Its closed front toilet has a modern appearance and is resistant to slamming, chipping, staining, and fading. It has a Slow Close feature that keeps the seat and lid from slamming shut.

Only when you gently tap the lid to close it do you come into contact with it. It also encourages hygiene for you, owing to fast release hinges that allow the seat to be readily removed for washing. Its removal does not necessitate the use of any tools.

It is meant to compliment any décor and is available at a low cost. Its consistent color throughout is resistant to scratches, fading, and flaking, and the 4 seat tight bumper preserves the stability of the seat, keeping it in place and preventing it from shifting. It can be set up in a matter of minutes thanks to its quick-attached hardware, which expedites the installation process.

Product Features

  • Dimensions: 16.81 x 14.31 x 2 inches (round)
  • Shape: elongated and round
  • Material: polypropylene
  • The slow-Close feature helps prevents slamming
  • Color: white
  • Mounting hardware and installation manual included

Pros

  • Resistant to staining, fading, chipping, and peeling
  • Fast and secure installation
  • Value for money
  • Sturdy
  • Easy to clean
  • No loud slamming
  • Durable

Cons

  • Flimsy mounting system

You may also be interested in:

Most Stain Resistant Toilet Seats

Best Most Comfortable Toilet Seats

Best Seniors Padded Toilet Seats


FAQS

Are Wooden Toilet Seats Sanitary?

Toilet seats made of wood have a protective coating that keeps them free of water and urine, enabling them to be utilized in a sanitary environment. If, on the other hand, the protective coating on the wooden seat starts to wear away, the seat may get wet, saturating the wood below it.

As a result, germs and bacteria will begin to colonize the porous wood that has been exposed to the elements.
As a result, in order to keep the toilet seat hygienic, it must be well-maintained and avoided from being slammed. Tiny fractures in the toilet seat will more than likely serve as a breeding ground for germs and will be a source of urine odor in the long term.

How to Correctly Maintain a Wooden Toilet Seat

The scratch and dent resistance of wood toilet seats is inferior to that of plastic toilet seats, and therefore they endure less time. Wooden furniture may be kept in excellent condition by using nonabrasive cleaning cloths or sponges.

If you want to get rid of germs, use antibacterial soap, hydrogen peroxide, or rubbing alcohol to wash your hands. Take extra care while washing the seat to make sure to completely rinse it with clean water and then use a dry, soft towel to dry it. Toilet doors should be left open to help keep hinges free of moisture. Bacteria, fungus, and mold may be present in the presence of moisture if the wood surface is provided with it.

You may want to try applying some wood glue to the nozzle of the dispenser to fix a broken toilet seat. To seal the gap, first apply the glue, then clamp the gap. After clamping, use a wet cloth to remove any excess wood glue.

Use mild hand soap and lots of water whenever you clean the toilet seat. The following cleaning and hygiene products should not be used: acid, detergents, bleach, scouring powder, essential oils, chlorine, pine, oils, and disinfectants, as well as items packed in aerosol cans.

Do Plastic Toilet Seats Stain?

A white toilet seat may get corroded as a result of the accumulation of minerals from hard water. You may use bleach, baking soda, or vinegar to prevent stains from forming.

In a mixing basin, combine 14 cup baking soda with 12 cup warm water to form a paste. Smear this mixture over the affected areas and let it to rest for 15 to 20 minutes before wiping away with a wet cloth or sponge to remove any remaining stain residue.

Why Are Toilet Seats Fond of Split In the Front?

Public toilets are divided because they must adhere to a plumbing regulation that is specific to public restrooms. They are industry-accepted standards that have been adopted by a large number of municipalities. The UPC is often included into the local codes of these towns.

All chairs that are accessible for public use in water closets must be of the open-front kind. To prevent genital contact with the lid, an area of the seat that might get contaminated with urine has been left exposed. By avoiding touch, wiping can be accomplished more quickly.

Later, a worldwide industry standard known as the Uniform Plumbing Code superseded the American Standard National Plumbing Code, and open-front toilet seats for public toilets have since been mandated. As a result, the true solution rests in the reason why they are included in the public plumbing code in the first place.

The U-shaped form of the seat is intended to make cleaning up after oneself simpler for women. This design provided greater accessibility for women and enabled them to use the toilet without the danger of damaging the porcelain.

How Do You Disinfect a Wooden Toilet Seat

Housecleaning may be done using bleach, baking soda, or vinegar. Everything is in excellent order. After cleaning the toilet, be sure to always clean it thoroughly and avoid leaving a seat on the toilet overnight. Once it has been cleaned, reattach it to the toilet.

In a basin mix vinegar with water, then use a soft cloth or a sponge to wipe clean the toilet seat. This is about wooden toilet seats, and what they offer, as well as any possible disadvantages. One must not pour water directly into the toilet tank. It should first be put into the toilet bowl and the bowl should be well cleaned.