Aquasana vs Pelican vs Jonathan Shower Filter – Which One Should You Buy?

The Pelican, Aquasana, and Jonathan shower filters fulfill the description given forth for very effective shower filters that eliminate chlorine, fluoride, odors, and significantly reduces other hazardous chemicals and contaminants from shower water.

Did you know that these chemicals strip natural oil from your skin and hair, resulting in dry flaky skin, premature aging, and wrinkles? The largest level of chlorine exposure happens during a hot shower. That brings me to an in-depth examination of these three market-leading shower filter brands.

In this guide, we conducted a thorough review and comparison based on performance data and user ratings, and we have settled on the best model that is effective, long-lasting, and cost-efficient, so keep reading to find out which one is the best.

 Disclaimer: Best Osmosis Experts is supported by readers. If you make a purchase after clicking on one of the links in this article, we may get an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you. 

Check our recommendation below.

Best Pick

Pelican Shower FilterCheck Today’s Price on Amazon

“Remove over 96% of chloramines and chlorine.”

Budget Pick

Jonathan Shower Filter SystemCheck Today’s Price on Amazon

“Balances water pH & remove Lead and Copper from tap water.”

Pelican vs Aquasana vs Jonathan Shower Filter Comparison Table

Features Pelican Shower Filter Aquasana Shower Filter Jonathan Shower Filter
1. Flow rate 1.5 2.5 2.5
2. Material Used Plastic Plastic Iron
3. Filtration Method Copper/zinc alloy Copper/zinc alloy Oxidation process
4. Gallons filtered 15,000 10,000 10,000
5. Lifetime 6 months 6 months 6 months
6. Chlorine removal 96% 95% 94%


Unfiltered water can dry up your skin, weigh down your hair, and cause brittle nails. Investing in an excellent shower filter can be beneficial to your overall health because these shower filters remove all traces of dangerous water contaminants that are present in our tap water.

To successfully reduce free accessible chlorine, a shower filter should have filter elements, and each element should be dosed to build the ultimate composition to assure you shower in toxic-free water, according to NSF/ANSI standards.

Overall, the Pelican Shower Filter included more modern technology that is designed to eliminate many of the usual chemicals from hard water, based on its affordability in conjunction with its features.

This shower filter captures hazardous chemicals and refreshes your water, leaving you with shiny, healthy hair and moisturized skin. Furthermore, it promises to provide filtered water that activates your cells, removes unpleasant odors, and eliminates chlorine and chloramine, which are responsible for dry skin.

Its shower water moisturizes, purifies, and softens the skin and body while providing the greatest experience for sensitive skin and body.

You can buy Pelican Shower Filter with confidence since it will protect your safety as well as the health and well-being of your family members by eliminating the serious health hazards associated with bathing in contaminated water.

Overall the Pelican Shower Filter has more advantages

Pelican PSF – 3 Stage Shower Filter Premium System (5-foot Wand) Pure White

Product Review: Pelican, Aquasana and Jonathan Shower Filter

1. Pelican Shower Filter Premium System (5-foot Wand) Review

As the name implies, the Pelican shower filter’s primary function is to provide quality water while taking a shower.

This model is directly placed on the shower spouts, and it comes with a 5-foot wand handheld massage wands available for purchase separately.


This model carries a 3-stage filtration system.

Stage 1 of the filtration removes chlorine and other contaminants and enhances pH balance with a natural zinc/copper mineral media called KDF-55D.

Copper and zinc are used in the construction of the KDF-55D filter, and the interaction of these two metals results in a tiny electrical chemical charge between them. More metal in your shower may seem counter-intuitive, but a KDF-55D filter is excellent for dissolving mercury, cadmium, arsenic, aluminum, and even chlorine from water.

The electric charge in your shower will go unnoticed, but the heavy metal will be felt immediately.

Stage 2 uses activated carbon media to remove synthetic chemicals, THMs, and chloramines that vaporize from shower water and are inhaled or absorbed through the skin, potentially causing adverse respiratory problems such as asthma. It will also eliminate unwanted odors, resulting in water that smells fresh and clean.

Stage 3 consists of far infrared balls that boast negative ions and oxygen levels in the water. Due to the water’s quality, there will be extra moisture in your skin and your hair, many buyers boast of improved moisturized skin and lustrous and shiny hair.

Pelican is so confident of the water-filtered effects under their system that they offer a money-back guarantee in cases where you do not experience the benefit it claims it would give you.

Its installation is known to take up less than 10 minutes. Any showerhead may be used in conjunction with it, and the shower filter cartridge can be replaced with a replacement shower filter cartridge at any time for your convenience.

Product features

  • Dimensions: 3.8 x 3.8 x 6.2 inches.
  •  Material: available in white and chrome finishes.
  • 1.5 GPM water flow.
  • 5- Foot tangle-free massage shower wand.
  •  Filters 15000 gallons.


  • Removes up to 96 percent of chlorine.
  • Simple to set up.
  • Good value for money.


  • The material used is plastic. Thus, high chances of breakage.

2. Aquasana Shower Filter System – NSF Certified KDF & Carbon Filtration Media

Aquasana shower filter system is manufactured by Sun Water Systems Inc, a company manufacturing high-end shower filters for the last 50 years.

Aquasana boasts of a dual selective filtration system. These filtration systems include carbon filtration, ion exchange, and sub-micron filtration.

These filtration systems work together to remove contaminants, including stubborn products of chlorine, toxic chemicals, sediments, impurities, and odors.

It also revitalizes dry skin and hair. In a nutshell, the shower filter reduces the serious health hazards associated with showering in hard water.

According to user evaluations, the Aquasana shower filter system installs in less than 10 minutes, is sturdy, and filters 10,000 gallons of fresh water every six months.

The shower filter delivers consistent water pressure due to its lightweight and ergonomic design, and its high-performance inline water filter will not diminish existing water pressure. Furthermore, the handheld shower wands can be purchased separately.

If you want the quickest, safest, simplest, and most cost-effective solution to naturally reduce naturally dry and flaky skin while promoting healthy skin, hair, and nails, the Aquasana Shower Filter System is one of the best options.

It boasts of several awards and citations. It was awarded the best water filter by the consumer’s Digest Best Buy Award for performance and cost per gallon. It garnered a Gold Customer Service Award and got a 4.9/ 5 rating.

This is a fantastic product that will care for your skin while also providing you with a soothing experience when showering.

Product features

  • Dimensions: 6.25 x 6.25 x 8.75 inches.
  • Material: iron.
  • Flow rate: 2.5 GPM.


  • One of the market’s longest-lasting shower filters.
  • Excellent value for money.
  • Hair and skin are not harmed.


  • It is quite costly in comparison to the rest.

3. Jonathan Shower Filter for Hard Water & healthy potassium ions to balance pH

If you have confidence in your water’s safety, but chlorine gives you dry skin, Jonathan Water Filter is another great way to go.

Jonathan water filter is a cost-effective two-stage shower filter that combines proven natural minerals that remove chlorine, chloramine, fluoride, and neutralizing odor to make your shower water cleaner, softer, and fresh.

The filtration system has been tested and certified to effectively remove chlorine and other heavy metals while replacing them with healthy potassium ions to balance the pH and neutralize the typical odor.

The filtration stage is an oxidation process that eliminates 91% of chlorine and preconditions the water for more filtration in the second stage.

The next step of the filtration stage uses activated carbon media with ion exchange to remove organic compounds and heavy metals. The complexion replaces the heavy metals with potassium ions producing clean fresh water just like natural spring water.

With Jonathan Shower Filter, you can be confident that it will significantly improve the condition of your skin and hair.

No tools are required just a hand to tighten the pipe connection and a bit of plumber tape included. No leaks no cracks.

The cartridge is rated to being able to purify around 10,000 gallons of water meaning one filter should last the average household for an average of 6 months. If your water is dirtier it will need to be replaced more often.

Product Features

  • Dimensions: 2 x 2 x 2 inches.
  • 91% chlorine hair & skin.
  •  Filters 10,000 gallons per cartridge at 2.5 gpm.
  • The material is made of iron that is accompanied with a chrome finish.
  • The Jonathan shower filter can be adjusted to a fixed shower head and handheld unit.


  • Improves the ph balance.
  • Removes copper and lead from water.
  • Simple to set up.
  • Heavy metals are filtered by this device.


  • Purchaser will be needed to purchase the full kit at the beginning.

Recommended Post

Aquasana vs Culligan Shower Filter

Detailed Comparison of Aquabliss SF220 vs SF100 vs SF500

What to Consider When Going For a Shower Filter

Although all the above water filteration systems are considered excellent models to remove water contaminants, they differ vastly from the initial cost to buy to the capacity and how much it costs to replace it.

If you think a filtration system that costs 25 cents a gallon to filter is going to be better than a system that costs 10 cents, then you’re wrong.

Second, there are other differences: Most appliances eliminate chlorine, but the quantities vary in the same way.
This is why if you value your health, you really must learn all about water contamination and which product will provide you with really clean, clear, pure water.

What to Look For In a Water-Filter

It would be best to look for a premium appliance that uses a twin cartridge system that will last you up to six months and costing no more than ten cents a gallon.

The best dual filter systems use a combination of carbon and sub-micron filtration alongside ion exchange. They remove all the nasty contaminants from your water, yet unlike reverse osmosis and distillation products, leave behind the minerals essential to your health.

Recently vitamin C has been considered one of the dechlorination methods in our American water works association standard (AWA).

This filtering technique has had such positive results that it has been included into the designs of numerous shower filter systems by manufacturers.
Plus, vitamin C and negative ions promote silky, shiny hair while making your shower water kinder and gentler on your skin.

The design of the shower filter should also be taken into consideration. The material should be a sturdy, durable material, a desirable shape, and a pleasant texture. Installation should be quick and easy without the need for special instruments.


Are shower filters worth it?

Shower filters are necessary these days. Numerous studies and probes have revealed that water over the world is contaminated with harmful chemicals that can lead to various health problems. So having some filter is better than no filter at all.
Since there are toxins in water, the obvious solution is to use a carbon filter, which can remove all contaminants, whether organic or synthetic. Carbon filters are the most convenient and low maintenance method for water filtration. When looking for water filters, buy a shower filter that does not strip water of its natural trace minerals like magnesium, potassium, and calcium, essential for good health.

How often should you replace a shower filter?

It would be best if you looked for a premium appliance that uses a twin cartridge system. The cartridge is rated to purify about 10,000 gallons of water, which means that one filter should serve an ordinary family six months at a cost of no more than ten cents per gallon, or six months on average. It’s important to note that if your water is dirtier, it will need to be replaced more often.

What happens when one doesn’t change the shower filter?

If you don’t replace the filter, it means you will start showering in unfiltered water. When you shower in unfiltered water, it’s not uncommon to invite unwanted bacteria, chemicals, and other nasty substances in your system that are toxic. Too much exposure can be very detrimental to your health.


As you can see, there are many essential points you need to consider when buying shower filters. With a water filter, the water coming out of the shower filter system is guaranteed to give you cosmetic benefits besides helping solve respiratory problems like asthma and general issues like dry skin dandruff and itching.

These water filtration systems also include minerals such as alkaline, ceramic balls and activated carbon, calcium sulfate, and other filtering materials that help to maintain a balanced pH and guarantee the greatest possible impact of water quality purification.

In order to protect your health, it is recommended that you install a shower filter. Filtering water in the home is a crucial step toward a healthier lifestyle. It remains that our bodies are more than 70 percent water, so it follows that the quality of our water supply has a profound effect on our health. Not only does shower filtration have internal health benefits, but your skin and hair are healthier, too, and permanents and color treatments last longer.

The advantages of having a filtered shower and filtering sink water are that when you filter out the chlorine and the other chemicals that have slipped through the city’s water treatment plants, you decrease your risks of inhaling the fumes created by these chemicals in your hot shower pelican water system. You eliminate the possibility that you will absorb the carcinogens through your skin. Nevertheless, it isn’t necessary once potentially deadly bacteria and pollutants have been removed, so it can safely be removed once it reaches your house. You can have better water without the expense of buying it.

Since the water standards are unlikely to change anytime soon because of the expense of improving the present systems and the lack of zeal over it in public, consumers must take measures themselves to protect themselves and their families.

Related Post

8 Top Shower Filter for Chlorine and Chloramine